Best Aquarium Test Kits - Water Chemistry Matters

July 14, 2019

Best Aquarium Test Kits - Water Chemistry Matters

Part of keeping and owning an aquarium is regularly testing your water. Testing your water is helps you understand your baselines and when to change water or adjust your supplementation. Using the best aquarium test kits you can afford or buy will make maintenance a lot easier on you. 

This blog is going to cover both freshwater and saltwater aquariums. Both freshwater and saltwater tanks have different things you will want to test for and different price ranges of kits. While it would be help to have separate post for freshwater or saltwater, the fact of the matter is that people will not find this guide as easily online if I posted in two separate posts so bear with me if you see a section that is not relevant to the aquariums you keep. Let's focus on what we test for first.

Parameters to Test In A Freshwater Aquarium

Let's talk about the parameters you want to test for in a freshwater aquarium. Below are the main parameters to test on a regular basis:

Ammonia

Ammonia is the result of waste being excreted from fish and decaying matter. There are two types of ammonia that are present in the aquarium, These are total ammonium (NH4) and free ammonia (NH3). Total ammonia is the ionized version of ammonia. While it is toxic, it is not as toxic as free ammonia. Most test kits will test for total ammonia, which can make the results of test not always as reliable. Free ammonia is the most dangerous form of ammonia. Test kits that detect free ammonia would be considered more reliable to use.

Nitrite

As bacteria breaks down ammonia, it converts ammonia to Nitrite, a less toxic substance. While it is less toxic than ammonia, over time, high levels of nitrite will disrupt the metabolism of your fish and eventually destroy their oxygen carrying cells, resulting in the suffocation and death of your inhabitants.

Nitrate

The third form of the nitrogen cycle. This is the least toxic of the 3 forms in the nitrogen and will be present in your water. At low levels these are not toxic to your fish, but at elevated levels this will cause stress to your fish and make them susceptible to disease.

Nitrates can be managed with a proper water change schedule.

pH

pH is the measurement of hydrogen ions. The lower the pH of the water, the more acidic it is and the higher the pH the more alkaline it is. In freshwater, different setups will have different pH needs so do your research on what pH level is desired for the inhabitants you keep. In general, pH for freshwater tanks range from 6-8. It is also important to point out that ammonia is more toxic to fish at higher pH levels and the production of nitrifying bacteria slows down when pH goes below 6.

Water Hardness

Water hardness is the measurement of calcium and magnesium ions. Some fish thrive in hard water, like cichlids while other fish like discus prefer soft water. Hardness is also really important for fish breeders, as some types of fry require soft water. To know your ideal hardness, it is best to research the specific type of fish you want to keep and check their requirements as it varies in freshwater tanks.

Carbonate Hardness (KH)

The range for KH depends on your inhabitants in tank. Some species prefer a lower KH while others require a higher. The key is once you know the  levels is to maintain in your tank.

Parameters to Test In A Freshwater Planted Tank

These are additional parameters to test in a freshwater planted tank.

Phosphate

Phosphate is a nutrient that supports photosynthesis. Is a parameter that is vital to maintain for freshwater tanks.

Iron

With planted tanks there are macronutrients to supplement like nitrogen, phosphorous, and potassium. Iron is what we call a micronurient. It is a trace element that is needed for plants and one of the common miconutrients that we monitor in planted tanks.

Parameters to Test In A Saltwater Aquarium

The main parameters in a saltwater tank is mostly the same in Ammonia, Nitrite, Nitrite, Phosphate, and pH. The other main parameter is salinity.

Before we go further, I need to disclosure there will be affiliate links below. Aquarium Store Depot may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page (learn more). The links here are suggestions for equipment and kit to purchase that will help you along your aquarium success journey.

Salinity can be measured with a refractometer and regularly calibrating it with a calibration fluid. For fish only, you can run your aquarium at 1.020, but reef tanks will generally run at 1.025 - 1.026 or 35 PPM.

Parameters to Test In A Saltwater Reef Aquarium

When you move into a saltwater reef tank, there are more parameters to test in order to ensure your corals thrive. Below are the main parameters to test.

Alkalinity

As mentioned in our Best Reef Salt Mix post, alkalinity is the fuel to build coral skeletons. Calcium and alkalinity relate to each which is way two-part solution is a common way of supplementing alkalinity.

Calcium

Calcium is used when corals build their skeletons and also by coralline algae. Without calcium, your corals will not build their skeleton and cannot maintain them.

Magnesium

This is the catalyst to for the reefs. Without magnesium, the elements in the reef tank cannot interact

Trace Elements

Elements like Silica, Iodine, Strontium, Boron, Iron, and minor trace elements are typically tested through ICP tests, which is something to consider if you are planning to run an advanced reef tank filled with Acropora corals.

The Best Aquarium Test Kits

As I stated earlier, in order to get the most people to view this post, I have to combine freshwater and saltwater test kits in one post. Below are the best test kits that get the job done for most aquarists.

Picture Name Best For Parameters Links
API Test Strips API Freshwater 5 in 1 Test Strips Freshwater Tanks Various

API Freshwater Master Test Kit API Freshwater Master Test Kit Freshwater Tanks Various

CO2 Drop Checker Solution C02 Drop Check Solution Planted Tanks CO2

Seachem Ammonia Alert (Buy On Amazon) Seachem Ammonia Alert All Tanks
Free Ammonia

Red Sea Marine Care Test Kit Red Sea Marine Care Multi Test Kit Saltwater Tanks Various

Salifert Master Reefing Test Combo Salifert Master Reef Test Kit Combo Reef Tanks Various

Nyos Nitrate Test Kit Nyos Nitrate Test Kit Saltwater Tanks Nitrate

Hanna Check Alkalinity Test Hanna Checker Alkalinity Test Kit Reef Tanks Alkalinity

Hanna Check Phosphate Test Kit Hanna Checker ULR Phosphate Test Kit Reef Tanks Phosphate

 

1. API Freshwater 5 in 1 Test Strips - Easy and Affordable Testing

API 5 in 1 Test Strips

The API 5 in 1 test strips are a great way for a beginner to test their freshwater tanks. The strips will test pH, Nitrite, Nitrate, Carbonate and General Hardness. With exception of ammonia, this has everything you need to test your freshwater aquarium. It is very easy to you as all you need to do is get some sample water from your aquarium and dip the strip. The results show up quickly you can compare to the color chart that comes with the kit. It is also one of the most affordable kits in the hobby.

Because it is so affordable, this is also the test kit you will see used by aquatic departments at chain pet stores. The test is also not super accurate, which is why this is not recommended for saltwater aquariums. It also lacks an ammonia test, so you will have to purchase a separate tester for that.  

Pros

  • 5 tests in one
  • Simple to use
  • Cheap

Cons

  • Free to get at many local chain stores
  • No ammonia test
  • Not super accurate

2. API Freshwater Master Test Kit - Test Kit of Choice For Beginners

 API Freshwater Master Test Kit

The API Freshwater Master Test Kit is a higher end version of their 5 in 1 test strips. This test kit allow you to check on your pH, Ammonia, Nitrite, and Nitrate levels. Because this kit uses a dropper in vials versus a strip, it is a little more complex to use but nothing a beginner can't figure out. This would be the recommended kit for the vast majority of fresh water hobbyists starting out. API also sells a API Saltwater Master Test Kit and a Reef Master Test Kit, but there are better test kits on this list better suited for saltwater and reef tanks. Overall, this is a comprehensive and affordable kit.

Just like with the test strips, due to its price this is also a very common test kit that specialty local fish stores will use when you bring in your water to test. Keep that in mind if you want to save some money or want to double verify results. My biggest gripe with this test is the ammonia test kit. It is a total ammonia kit not a free ammonia tester. Because of that, it is common to get false positives, especially on the saltwater kit (which is why I don't recommend them for saltwater tanks). The color gauge isn't that easy to read as well. 

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Has all the basic parameter needs to test in a freshwater tank

Cons

  • Usually free to get at specialty local fish stores
  • Ammonia test is total ammonia not free ammonia test
  • Color gauge can be hard to read or interpret at times

3. CO2 Drop Check Solution - CO2 Testing for Planted Tanks

CO2 Drop Check Solution for Planted Tanks

One of the trickier things to do in a freshwater planted tank is testing your CO2 levels. The CO2 drop checker solution is a great way to consistency monitor your CO2 levels. It works in conjunction with a Glass CO2 checker that you will need to purchase separately. It's a reasonably priced solution that is easy to setup in a planted tank. You can always make your own test solution, which is detailed in the video below.

To me, this is essential test equipment for a serious planted tank. The color chart can be a little hard to read at times, but if you want to monitor your CO2 levels constantly, this is the way to go.

Pros

  • You can actually test your CO2 levels now
  • Has all the basic parameter needs to test in a freshwater tank

Cons

  • Needs a CO2 glass drop checker
  • Color chart can be hard to read

4. SeaChem Ammonia Alert - Free Ammonia Tester

SeaChem Ammonia Alert

The SeaChem Ammonia Alert badge has been a mainstay for me in every aquarium I have setup. I use them on every quarantine tank I use and they go into freshwater and saltwater tanks. What sets this ammonia tester apart from others is that it is a free ammonia tester. Free ammonia is the type of ammonia we really want to look out for as it is the most deadly. Many test kits only measure total, which doesn't give you the full picture. It also measures your ammonia levels 24-7 so you will know right away if something is off. Given they work 24-7 and last a good bit, the price isn't that bad when you think about it.

The main thing with these kits is getting a proper read on the badge. I would recommend that you shine a light on the back of the badge to get an accurate measurement if you can't tell if it is yellow or another color. They also tend to last more like 3-6 months instead of a year. Overall, these have served me very well over the years and I continue to use them. 

Pros

  • Monitors free ammonia 
  • Monitors ammonia levels 24-7
  • Cheap

Cons

  • Can be hard to read
  • Usually won't last for a year like the package states

5. Red Sea Marine Multi-Test Kit - The Best Saltwater Starter Test Kit

Red Sea Marine Mult-Test Kit

When I talked to people just starting out in the saltwater tank hobby and they are looking for a saltwater test kit, the Red Sea Marine Care Multi Test Kit is my usual recommendation. This test kit includes tests for Ammonia, Nitrate, Nitrite, pH, and Alkalinity. It is a very generous test kit as well as you get 100 ammonia tests and 100 nitrate test. This should easily last you until the test kits expire. 

I prefer this test over because they are superior quality then what the local specialty stores will usually use (API) and the nitrate test kit has a large range. Red Sea sells a nitrate pro test kit which has two different tests for low and high range. I prefer this test kit over the pro as the majority of beginners shouldn't really have to work with ultra low levels of nitrates.

I also really like how this includes an Alkalinity test, which will help ease your way into reef tank keeping if you chose to do that in the future.

It is a pricey kit compared to what API offers, but it's a sound investment if you want to dive into saltwater aquarium keeping.

Pros

  • Includes alkalinity test
  • Good ammonia test kit
  • Easy to read for a beginner kit

Cons

  • Fairly pricey
  • Nitrate test is not low range for ultra low nutrient tanks

6. Red Sea Marine Multi-Test Kit - The Best Saltwater Starter Test Kit

Salifert Multi Test Kit

When I talk to folks who are starting to get into reef tanks and want a comprehensive test kit that covers all essential parameters of a reef tank, I point them towards the Salifert Test Kit Combos. This has 6 tests in total, pH, Nitrate, Magnesium, Phosphate, Alkalinity, and Calcium. You can run any reef tank setup you desire with this test kit package. 

This will get you going for a reef tank. It is on the pricey side, but keep in mind that you are getting 6 test kits at once. For those of you looking for a digital readout that is easy to read, look at the Hanna Checkers listed below in this post.

Pros

  • Comprehensive - has every test kit you need to run a reef tank
  • High quality test kits overall
  • One of the better calcium test kits on the market

Cons

  • Pricey
  • No digital read out like Hannas

7. Nyos Nitrate Test Kit - Best Nitrate Test Kit For Saltwater Tanks

Nyos Nitrate Test Kit

If I have a saltwater hobbyist looking for a high quality nitrate test kit as a single purchase, the Nyos Nitrate Test Kit is the test I recommend. It's the easy to read, easiest to know, one of the most accurate, and covers a wide range of levels. 

I actually have a Red Sea test kit that I usually use, but once I ran out of nitrate tests, I switched to this kit. It's just far easier to use and read in my opinion and I continue to use this kit today on my reef tanks.

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Cheaper than other kits
  • Easy to read results

Cons

  • No ideal for ultra low nutrient tanks

8. Hanna Checker Alkalinity Test Kit - The Best Alkalinity Tester for Reef Tanks

Hanna Check Alkalinity Test Kit

Reef tank enthusiasts demand high end solutions for their aquariums. The Hanna Checker Alkalinity tester is one such solution. It is a very easy to use and very accurate test kit. I am a big fan of Hanna Checkers because they give you a digital readout so there is no guess work on reading some color chart or trying to figure out the colors. 

It is a expensive kit though. The kit itself is as expensive as the test combos from Salifert and Hanna is known for having test regents that do not last very long. The refills from Hanna will only last 25 tests so keep this in mind if you want to purchase one. It is a very accurate kit though and I would highly recommend it if you are planning to keep a high end reef full of stony corals.

Pros

  • Extremely accurate with no guess work
  • Very quick to test

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Regents do not last very long

9. Hanna Checker ULR Phosphate Test Kit - The Best Phophate Tester for Reef Tanks

Hanna ULR Phosphate Test Kit

Phophate testing is a major deal in a reef tank. Too low can result in nuisance outbreaks like dinoflagellates and bleaching of stony corals while too high can lead to nuisance algae. I prefer Hanna's ULR Phosphate tester over their standard test as it is more accurate. 

This is an expensive test kit, but it is the phosphate tester of choice in the industry without a doubt.

Pros

  • Extremely accurate with no guess work
  • Very quick to test

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Regents do not last very long

Frequently Asked Questions About Aquarium Test Kits

How Often Should I Test My Aquarium Water?

I would recommend that you test your water once a week, on the same day, and around the same time. Let your test parameters dictate when you need to make a water change. This statement is especially relevant for heavily planted freshwater tanks and saltwater tanks with live rock and corals. Plants and corals can remove nitrates and phosphates in the aquarium to the point where you may not need to do water changes as frequently. In these environments, you can have water that is too clean which means your plants and corals may not thrive because nutrients are not available for your plants and corals to grow. As long as you test every week you can say on top of the changes in you aquarium and adjust your maintenance and dosing schedule as needed.

Do Aquarium Test Kits Expire?

They actually do. Most test kits will expire in about 1 to 2 years. You should always check the expiration on your test kits and replace when the date passes. The expiration is a guarantee on accuracy as the regents lose their potency over time leading to less accurate tests. 

What is the Best Freshwater Test Kit?

I feel that the API Master Test Kit is the best freshwater kit available. It has just about everything you need to start out and is fairly accurate for most freshwater hobbyist. It is cheap and will last a long time. Really can't ask for more.

What is the Best Saltwater Test Kit?

Without a doubt, the Red Sea Marine Care Multi Test Kit is the best core test kit to buy for a saltwater aquarium. It is a higher grade test than what you will get at the local fish store and it comes with an alkalinity tester so you are covered if you decide to move onto a reef tank in the future.

What is the Best Saltwater Reef Test Kit?

If you are looking for the highest grade equipment for your reef tank, you cannot go wrong with Hanna Checkers for Alkalinity and Phosphate. For Nitrate, I feel the that Nyos test kit is the best. For everything else, I would consider Salifert.

If you are running a high end SPS coral tank with designer acropora, I would highly recommend doing ICP testing to regularly check on all essential parameters.

Conclusion To Best Aquarium Test Kits

Aquarium test kits do not need to be complicated. As you have seen from many of these test kits, nearly all of them are easy to use and understand. Test is a regular part of aquarium maintenance and continue to test your water weekly to keep up with changes in your tank. This will allow you to respond before things go downhill. I hope this guide help you get the test kits that work with your budget and needs for your aquarium. Thanks for reading.

 





Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in The AquariumStoreDepot.com blog

The Best Substrate for Planted Tanks – 2019 Reviews & Guide
The Best Substrate for Planted Tanks – 2019 Reviews & Guide

November 17, 2019

As we mentioned in our Best Low Light Aquarium Plants article. There are some plants that require rich substrates to thrive and others that are column feeders. Today's post we are going to concentrate on selecting the best substrate for your planted tank. There are many factors that go into selecting the best substrate and there are a ton of questions aquarists want answered before they they start planting. I will go through as much as I can in this post to provide you the best information possible and then suggest several great substrates that should work for your planted aquarium. 

View full article →

Best Low Light Aquarium Plants - Making An Easy to Keep Planted Tank
Best Low Light Aquarium Plants - Making An Easy to Keep Planted Tank

November 10, 2019

Many of us who want a planted tank want to have an easy to maintain tank that that doesn't really take a ton of effort to keep up. Today's post is all about that. The list we will make today will help you find plants that are easy to maintain and grow fast to provide a great aquascape for your planted tank. These plants are low light aquarium plants, which means they will not require sizable investments in powerful lights to keep. Many of them will thrive without CO2 supplementation, which will also save you money in the long-run. 

All these plants are readily available as well. They are relevantly cheap and easy to find available. With that, let's go ahead and get started!

View full article →

Best Auto Top Off System - Keeping Your Aquarium Stable (2019 Reviews)
Best Auto Top Off System - Keeping Your Aquarium Stable (2019 Reviews)

October 20, 2019

Aquarium automatic is becoming more and more of a reality to the modern aquarist these days. One of the most common applications of tank automation are auto top of systems (AKA ATOs). These systems work to add freshwater to your aquarium as water evaporates. In saltwater tanks in particular, they are extremely valuable in maintaining stable salinity levels as salinity can swing as water evaporates and does not get replaced. In freshwater tanks, this will keep your water levels stable so your filtration can run optimally and so your tank doesn't completely dry out.

View full article →