Best Protein Skimmer Reviews - (2019 Reviews & Guide)

February 15, 2019

Best Protein Skimmer Reviews - (2019 Reviews & Guide)

Today's post is discussion the protein skimmer, often times the workhorse of a saltwater aquarium. The best protein skimmers are the heart of a system and even for some systems that put refugiums first, a protein skimmer is still a major component of the life support system in the reef. 

Skimmers have been around a very long time and have been implemented in large tanks, public aquariums, aquaculture faculties, and fish stores. I'll explain further on how skimmers work, what types of protein skimmers are available, and go through a list of the best protein skimmers available for purchase today.

What is a Protein Skimmer?

A protein skimmer is a filtration unit that removes protein and other organic waste. It works by relying on a chemical process to remove waste from the water column. Waste will adhere to the surface of air bubbles produced by the protein skimmer and are literally pulled out of the water by the thousands of air bubbled produced by the skimmer. 

Along with aquarium usage, protein skimmers are used in commercial applications like municipal water treatment facilities. They have been around for many years and are a tried and true filtration technology.

Tidal gardens breaks down protein skimmers in the video below:

Types of Protein Skimmers

Protein skimmers are unfortunately one of the saltwater aquarium products that is plagued with tons of marketing fluff. I'm going to attempt to simplify the discussion by breaking down protein skimmers by type and the differences below:

Internal Protein Skimmers

These are protein skimmers you will typically see in nano tanks. They are usually air stone driven and generally, the quality of them really is not that great. Unless you are purchasing a highly internal skimmer, we would recommend you save your money and opt for high quality live or aquacultured rock.

Hang On Back Protein Skimmers - AKA HOB Protein Skimmers

A hang on back protein skimmer (HOB) is a skimmer that is designed to work without an aquarium sump. The skimmers will hang on the back of the tank and will pull water directly out of the display tank. While they are great for smaller tanks or tanks that do not have a sump, they often time are not as powerful and comprehensive compared to in sump protein skimmers. They also tend to leave a pretty sizable footprint in the tank as the pump needs to sit in the display tank, which leaves aesthetics to be desired.

In Sump Protein Skimmers

These are where the vast majority of the best protein skimmers fall under. The best manufacturers of skimmers make them to operate inside a sump as many reef tank keepers maintain an large aquarium sump that can hold these units. They offer lots of features like needle wheels, some are DC powered, and others are recirculating protein skimmers which provide even more cleaning power. We highly recommend shopping for an in sump protein skimmer.

External Protein Skimmers

These protein skimmers are usually meant for larger aquariums or commercial applications. They are often sold for aquariums over 300 gallons and most smaller aquarium setups do not have the room to house these. If you are a monster fish keeper with a fish room, a commercial external protein skimmer might be on your radar.

Do You Really Need A Protein Skimmer?

The short answer is no. However, many successful reefers and saltwater aquarium keepers use them because they are excellent tools of filtration and the best protein skimmers can do an incredible job of keeping nitrates and phosphates low when working in conjunction with a refugium or as part of a refugium sump build. Less phosphates and nitrates means you can keep lower levels for your fish and corals or even control your levels and dose up to the levels you prefer to stay at and maintain a healthy low term tank.

A protein skimmer has been essential to many of the key methods of filtration used by high end reefers today. The skimmer was one of the cornerstones of the Berlin Method that utilized live rock and protein skimmers and still is a preferred method of filtration for large coral sellers like World Wide Corals. The protein skimmer is also a key component of the Triton Method of filtration, which is a high level method of reef keeping that involves a skimmer, a large refugium, dosing of trace elements and supplements in order to keep an aquarium free of water changes.

So with both of these points stated, I would say it is a recommended piece of equipment for a saltwater aquarium.

Best Protein Skimmer Reviews

As I stated earlier, protein skimmers have a ton of marketing fluff behind them and that makes it difficult to find a protein skimmer that will work for your needs. I'm going to provide a list of recommended skimmers from all price ranges that we known have been part of very successful reef tank builds. We will also list out the only hang on back protein skimmer we recommend.

So without further ado, here is the list:

Picture Name Sump Type Links
AquaMaxx HOB Skimmer AquaMaxx HOB 1.5  Hang On Back
Macro Aqua M-50 HOB Skimmer Macro Aqua M-50 Hang On Back
Bubble Magus Curve Skimmer Bubble Magus Curve Series In Sump
Nyos Quantum Skimmer Nyos Quantum  In Sump 
IceCap K-2 Skimmer Review IceCap K-2  In Sump
IceCap K-1 Skimmer Review IceCap K-1 In Sump
Reef Octopus Protein Skimmer Review Reef Octopus Classic In Sump
Reef Octopus eSsence Protein Skimmer Review Reef Octopus Essence In Sump
Reef Octopus Regal Protein Skimmer Review Reef Octopus Regal In Sump (DC)
SCA Protein Skimmer Review SCA Protein Skimmer In Sump
Simplicity Protein Skimmers

Simplicity DC Protein Skimmers

In Sump (DC)

 

1. Aquamxx HOB 1.5 - The Best Hang on Back Protein Skimmer on the Market

Aquamaxx HOB 1.5 Protein Skimmer Review

For many years, the Aquamaxx HOB Protein Skimmer has held the title of best hang-on skimmer on the market. This new 1.5 remodel amps up the skimming power to the pinnacle of what HOB skimmers are capable of.  

Armed with a Sicce rebranded "Shark"pump, this skimmer has all the power that an in-sump skimmer can provide but with the ability to be placed on the back of an aquarium. It is even compact enough to fit in larger all in one aquariums like the Innovative Marine 40.

The main complaint with this unit is the footprint inside of the tank. It does take away at the aesthetics using an HOB and the price is on par with many in-sump skimmers. It is the choice for HOB skimmers without a doubt!

Pros

  • Powerful skimmer - the best hang on back protein skimmer
  • Italian pump built to last
  • Compact enough to work in larger all in one systems

Cons

  • Hang on backs take up space in the aquarium
  • Price

2. Macro Aqua M-50 - The Budget HOB Protein Skimmer

Macro Aqua M-50 Protein Skimmer Review

If you are looking for a cheap protein skimmer that works, the Macro Aqua M-50 is the protein skimmer that you are looking for! There are many protein skimmers that are cheap that are absolute junk like the old sea clones or air stone driven skimmers. The Macro Aqua differs from these as it uses a needle wheel pump to run the protein skimmer. 

What you get is a wet skimmate production, but that is adequate for many smaller systems. The price really can't be beat unless you start making some huge sacrifices in quality or function.

My main gripe with this skimmer is the noise factor. It just is not that quiet, but given the price, something has got to give!

Pros

  • Cheap!
  • Needle wheel skimmer

Cons

  • Loud
  • Not the best skimmate compared to high quality and more expensive offerings 

3. Bubble Magus Curve - The Original Bang For the Buck Protein Skimmer

Bubble Magus Curve Protein Skimmer Review

The original Bubble Magus Curve series protein skimmers are the original bang for the buck protein skimmer. This is the protein skimmer that has been used by many reefers with great series. You can probably call this the Chinese Black Box LED equivalent for protein skimmers.

These are very practical and efficient skimmers. They are armed with a needle wheel pump and the modern curve skimmer body that are commonplace with higher end protein skimmers.

The main con with this unit is the dial in time. They really take their time breaking in and the pump isn't as high quality as other protein skimmers on this list. But the great thing now is Bubble Magus came out with the Bubble Magus Curve Elite Protein Skimmers that are armed with a Sicce pump. These elites are now up there with the top brands and deserve your attention!

Pros

  • Cheap!
  • Lots of features from higher end skimmer models
  • Elite versions are available for those wanting an Italian made pump

Cons

  • They take time to break in and can be finicky
  • The original curve's pump is above average - upgrade to the elites for higher quality

4. Nyos Quantum - Incredible Quality With No Break In Time

Nyos Quantum Skimmer Review

The Nyos Quantum in my mind is the pinnacle of AC powered protein skimmers. Made in Germany, this skimmer is designed for extreme performance. The German made pump is designed for power and silence, providing one of the quietest protein skimmers available. The skimmer is expertly crafted and designed to last throughout the life of your tank. It is built to be disassembled so cleaning and maintaining is very painless with this skimmer. They also seemingly seem to break in very fast, nearly having no break in time!

Quality does come with a price. This is one of the most expensive protein skimmers on the market, but you definitely get what you pay for. 

Pros

  • German made skimmer
  • Expertly crafted and incredible performance
  • Easily disassembled for cleaning

Cons

  • Expensive!

5. IceCap K-2 - A Solid Mid-Price Skimmer

 Ice Cap K-1 Protein Skimmer Reviews

The CoralVue IceCap K-1 Skimmers are the main line of CoralVue skimmer offerings. They are mid-priced skimmers that offer a lot of value and features for the money. Like many of the higher end skimmers, this K-1 skimmer is equipped with the iconic Italian made Sicce pump. The skimmer has some extra touches with marking on the collection cup and adjustment dials so you know what levels you have adjusted to. This pipeless design also allows for a quieter operation than lower budget range skimmers.

It's overall a really good value, with my only hesitation is that it may be still out of range for some reefers budgets.

Pros

  • Mid-Priced skimmer with high-end features
  • Italian made Sicce pump
  • Smaller footprint to comparable skimmers

Cons

  • Still a little out of range for some mid-priced shoppers

6. IceCap K-1 - An IceCap Skimmer for The Budget Conscious Reefer

IceCap K-1 Protein Skimmer Reviews

For those of you who like what the IceCap K-2 skimmers offer, but not in their budgets, the IceCap K-1 protein skimmers are a great alternative. The K-1 offers the same features as the K-2 with the exception of the pump. You still get the markings and a professional level adjustable valves.

While all the features offered are great, you are sacrificing the pump quality. The pump included here is a wavereef pump, which is a step down for the benchmark Sicce pumps that many reef veterans trust. It is nonetheless a great value offer for budget conscious saltwater aquarists.

Pros

  • A budget conscious, but value loaded skimmer
  • Various models sizes available for all sizes of aquariums
  • Compact Size

Cons

  • Pump is a wavereef pump - it's not a Sicce

7. Reef Octopus Classic - Quality Name Brand Skimmer With High End Performance

Reef Octopus Classic Protein Skimmer Reviews

Reef Octopus Classic Skimmers have been been unchanged for a very long time. The newest remodel of these skimmers of the classic line is an improvement over the decade old proven reliability of these series of protein skimmers.

The Reef Octopus brand is well known in the marine reef industry and has a long standing quality reputation among the community. They were the first protein skimmer manufacturers in the world that designed their very own protein skimmer pumps. When you purchase a Reef Octopus, you know you are purchasing a skimmer with a pump specifically designed for the protein skimmer instead of the typical bolted on 3rd party pump that other manufacturers use.

Reef Octopus further backs up their product with a 2 year warranty versus your typical 1 year warranty. The also have a Reef Octopus Space Saver Protein Skimmer model for those with small sumps.

Our only con to report on the classic line is the price. When these new classic models were released that came with an increased price, but you get what you pay for.

Pros

  • Respected Reef Octopus name and quality
  • Skimmer pump is designed specifically for the skimmer
  • 2 year warranty

Cons

  • Price

8. Reef Octopus Essence - High End Protein Skimmer with Convenience Features

Reef Octopus Essence Protein Skimmer Review

The Reef Octopus Essence series protein skimmer take what we love about the classic series and adds an number of hobby friendly maintenance features.

The skimmer cup has an easy to use twist and lift feature and there is a detachable silence collar that makes the skimmer super quiet. There are quick release tabs that are very similar to what bubble magus features that allows you easy access to the skimmer body for cleaning. They are designed to have a small footprint so you can fit these in tight spaces and the dials have a nice extra touch of being marked.

This is a skimmer for those who want simplicity. It does come with a price though as they are more expensive than the classic series skimmers. Overall, it's a great product release by Reef Octopus.

Pros

  • Respected Reef Octopus name and quality
  • Has a number of hobby friendly convenience features
  • 2 year warranty

Cons

  • Price - more expensive than classic line

9. Reef Octopus Regal - High End DC Protein Skimmers with Serious Reefkeepers

Reef Octopus Regal Protein Skimmer Reviews

The Reef Octopus Regal Protein Skimmer is the first skimmer on the list that is DC Powered. This is the top of the line skimmer series from Reef Octopus and it puts out no stops in providing the best of the best that current skimmer technology can offer. The heart of the system is a the very high quality Reef Octopus VarioS DC Pump that is the considered the overall best aquarium return pump in the industry. 

This skimmer has the same high quality construction that you would expect from any Reef Octopus skimmer. The DC pump provides enhanced control, performance, and energy efficiency that puts it at another level compared to traditional AC powered options.

It's a top of the line protein skimmer, so it commands a top of the line price. Again with Reef Octopus, you get what you pay for. There is also the Regal INT protein skimmer models for those who have additional space in their sumps.

Pros

  • DC Powered protein skimmer - enhanced controllability
  • Very powerful and efficient
  • Very high quality DC pump that is built to last

Cons

  • Price - most expensive protein skimmer on this list

10. SCA Protein Skimmers - The In Sump Protein Skimmer for the the Ultra Budget Conscious

SCA Protein Skimmer Reviews

The SCA Protein Skimmer is the cheapest in sump protein skimmer on this list and it's actually a pretty decent skimmer. It powered by an Atman skimmer pump, which is a value pump that is used to replace more expensive skimmer pumps, but it is plenty serviceable here.

The main value here is the simple construction of the skimmer. It is really simple to setup and use and just has all the bare essentials to get you skimming all the junk out of your tank.

The main gripes I have with this skimmer is the pump and the the maintenance. The pump isn't the best and I tend to be bias for Sicce pumps and the body doesn't have a quick release like the Bubble Magus or Essence skimmers.

Pros

  • Cheap!
  • Simple construction and easy to use

Cons

  • The Atman skimmer is just an average skimmer pump
  • It uses nuts instead of a quick release for the skimmer body

11. Simplicity DC Protein Skimmers - A Value DC Power Protein Skimmer

Simplicity DC Protein Skimmer Reviews

If you are looking for a DC Protein Skimmer, but do not want to spend an arm and a leg, the Simplicity DC Protein Skimmers are an incredible value. The adjustable speed of the DC speed offers incredible adjust-ability with these skimmers and silent functionality.

It is simple to use, which makes sense given the name brand and due to the DC pump takes less time to break in than traditional protein skimmers. Simplicity is also known for having great customer service, so you will have a good experience with support versus other value line protein skimmers.

The price is in line with many mid-grade protein skimmer so you are getting a skimmer with the higher end features of a DC protein skimmer, but with the price of a mid-grade skimmer.

There are only two things I see as cons with this protein skimmer. The first is that the skimmer body is held together with nylon bolts so it's not a quick release like the others on this list. The other is the pump itself. The protein skimmer pump is a re-branded Jabeo which makes us question the long term reliability of the pump. The good thing though this also means that the pump is cheap to replace

Pros

  • DC powered skimmer = lots of controlability 
  • Cheap for a DC skimmer!
  • Excellent customer service from Simplicity

Cons

  • No quick release function for skimmer body
  • DC Pump reliability could be questionable

Our Best Protein Skimmer Recommendations

This is a tough one because there are a lot of high quality protein skimmers on the list. I'm actually going to list several here as each of these recommendations would fit different tanks. Before I provide the list I will say I'm a big advocate of Reef Octopus protein skimmers, but they don't really fit with any of the category winners below:

Beginners Protein Skimmers FAQs

The following FAQs are below for common questions. If you have additional questions,  please leave a comment.

Can A Protein Skimmer Be Used in Freshwater Tanks?

Generally no. The reason why skimmers do not work in freshwater is due to surface tension. They are best used in environments with a high level of dissolved organics in the water (e.g. - dirty). This means that heavy duty applications are the only realsitic means of use like commercial fish farms or large ponds. For most hobbyists running a freshwater tank, a simple water change is far more convenient and easier to do.

Do Protein Skimmers Remove or Reduce Nitrates?

They do not directly, but they do so indirectly with how they work. Protein skimmers remove organic waste out of the water column, which in effect will lower the concentration of nitrates over time. It is common for high end skimmers to run a tank "too clean" so the best answer is - indirectly yes they do.

Will A Protein Skimmer Help With My Algae Problem?

Indirectly yes. Protein skimmers will remove nutrients for algae by removing the organic pollutants. I still believe that growing a marco source of algae like cheato can be very useful in choking out nuisance algae.

Should I Run My Protein Skimmer All The Time?

You certainty can and most people do. Monitoring your parameters with a quality test kit should give you a better answer though. If your levels are too low for your corals, you might want to consider leaving your skimmer operating less than 24 hours a days. This is easily controlled with an aquarium controller, or plugging your skimmer to a smart power strip, where you can set a schedule for it.

Where Should I Put A Protein Skimmer In My Sump?

This is a preference related question. However, I will state that the worse place to put a protein skimmer would be in the return chamber of your sump. That leaves us with either the first or second chamber and that's the part that is going to depend on your saltwater tank build.

Traditionally, a protein skimmer is best placed in the first chamber of your sump. The reason why is your protein skimmer is your first filtration device after your filter socks or media cups (if you use either). This allows for cleaner water to pass through your other sections in the sump. This is my usual recommended place to put a skimmer.

There is a newer method of system now called the Trition method that places the protein skimmer in the second chamber. Placing the skimmer in the second chamber allows for a great chance of pops populating in your refugium section and a high volume refugium. Some Triton systems will run socks though and I can tell you from experience that socks love to catch pods so to me if you are going to do Triton you should consider ditching your socks and living with a dirtier looking sump. Check out our best aquarium sump reviews for more info about the best sump available for your reef tank.

Best Protein Skimmer Reviews Conclusion

My goal with these blog posts is to make you as well informed as possible with the products you are looking to purchase so you can make the best decision for your aquarium. I hope I achieved this. If you think I missed something, please feel free to leave a comment. See you next time! 

 

 





Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in The AquariumStoreDepot.com blog

Bubble Tip Anemone Care Guide (Have Success with BTAs)
Bubble Tip Anemone Care Guide (Have Success with BTAs)

April 16, 2019

Many of us got interested in saltwater fish by seeing clownfish and anemones. It is a very common desire to eventually want to pair your clown with an anemone. While a captive raised clownfish is a easy to care for fish, an anemone is considered a more difficult to keep invertebrate. They require stability, a high amount of light, and good flow. I'm writing this guide because I get asked a lot from clients how they can keep an anemone. I'm going to focus today on the easiest to keep anemone that a clownfish will host - the bubble tip anemone.

View full article →

Best Aquarium Return Pumps (2019 Reviews) - AC vs DC What Works Best?
Best Aquarium Return Pumps (2019 Reviews) - AC vs DC What Works Best?

April 14, 2019

Return pumps are an essential component for many fish tanks. They are used in all-in-one tanks, water changing stations, and in aquariums sumps or refugium sumps. It is the heart of the aquarium and thus the very piece of equipment in your setup that you do not want to fail. You can argue that next to an Aquarium Heater, a failed return pump can be disastrous not only for your livestock, but to your home in the event of a flood or leak.

The goal with this post is not to point you to the cheapest aquarium return pumps or the most expensive ones. I'm going to point you to the highest quality and reliable pumps available today on the market. This is a component of your system that you should not skim on. You want an aquarium return pump to last forever, be quiet, and to be relevantly maintenance free.

View full article →

Best Aquarium Wavemaker Reviews (2019 Reviews)
Best Aquarium Wavemaker Reviews (2019 Reviews)

March 30, 2019

Technology has gone a far way since I started in aquariums. Before, there were standard powerheads that would distribute a fixed flow and stream in your water column. Now you have these items called wavemakers that provide a wider and more powerful stream of water flow in your aquarium. A lot of manufacturers have entered the fray release their own wavemakers, but what is the best aquarium wavemaker? 

There are so many wavemakers out there and now there are DC powered wavemakers that have a ton of controllability. Which one is the right one for you? Today's post hopefully will clear that all up for you in deciding what wavemaker will work best for your aquarium.

View full article →