Goldfish Tank - Your Guide To Successful Goldfish Care

February 29, 2020

Gold Fish Tank

The Goldfish is one of the most popular fish in our aquarium hobby. It may even have been the first fish you had when you first got introduced to aquariums. You may have even come across this article thinking about setting up a Goldfish tank for the first time or for a loved one. They really are an amazing fish that are also easily misunderstood. Because they are usually a first-time fish, a number of us enter into Goldfish care and keeping with little knowledge on what is needed to have them thrive.

I'm sharing this article with you today so you can learn all the essentials plus more. I want you to be very successful with caring for your pet Goldfish. As quick disclosure, this blog post will contain affiliate links which I may get a small commission at no extra cost to you should you make a purchase. Now let's get started!

All About Goldfish (History of Goldfish)

One crazy fact about Goldfish is that they were first kept for their meat. Yes, that's right. Goldfish used to be what was for dinner in China, their area of origin. Goldfish are the domesticated version of wild carp from East Asia. Their original colors were a silver-grey and they were known as "chi" in the East. It was one of the most common staples of meat in China at one time.

Common Carp

As carp continued to be bred for meat, a strange thing happened. Genetic mutations would occur with the carp and these "mutants" would end up with flashy red, yellow, and orange colors. If these fish were in the wild, they would get quickly eaten by predators since they stood out so much. These flashy looking new fish caught the eye of Buddhist monks in the 9th century. They began to keep these colorful fish in their ponds. The Goldfish was born at this time as an ornamental pet. 

The breeding of the fancy Goldfish varieties did not begin until the 1600s starting in Ming Dynasty China. They were highly regarded for their scales and it was tradition for a man to give his wife a goldfish on their first anniversary to symbolize the prosperous years to come. Goldfish were imported to North America around the 1850s.

Goldfish Care - The Major Factors We Need To Know

Goldfish on the surface seem very hardy and easy to take care of. For the most part, they are. However, we want to have the the best environment we can place them in. I want to go beyond the basic beginner setup and set you up for long-term success. Goldfish care can be broken down into several parts:

  • Housing
  • Filtration
  • Temperature
  • Decor
  • Substrate
  • Diet
  • Tank Mates

Goldfish Tank Size

I'm going to say it upfront to my readers. Goldfish do not belong in a Goldfish bowl. You may see Goldfish bowls everywhere, but bowls are not big enough for them long-term. You may purchase them as young new fish for your fish tank, but they will get large. In fact, the Common Goldfish can grow up to 10 inches in size and Fancy Goldfish can grow up to 8 inches in length. That is a lot of Goldfish for a tank! Goldfish also have a lot of mass, especially the Fancy types. Given their adult sizes, it's no wonder they were originally kept in ponds.

When sizing an aquarium for a Fancy Goldfish, you will want to start out with a tank size of 20 gallons for a single Fancy. After that it's roughly 10 gallons per every other Fancy Goldfish. This means a 40 gallon tank can hold 4 adult sized Fancy Goldfish. That doesn't sounds like a lot of fish, but remember they get pretty big. We need to ensure an aquarium is big enough not only for them to have room to swim around, but also so you are not a slave to water changes.

For a common variety of Goldfish like a Comet, you will want to consider a aquarium size of 30 gallons and target at least 4 feet in length. Each subsequent comet you add would need an additional 12 gallons so for a 55 gallon tank, we are talking about 3 full size Comets. Again, not a lot of fish. Keep in mind that Comets can grow up to 12 inches in length!

For a Fancy Goldfish setup, I would recommend a larger aquarium like this Fluval 45 Bowfont.  This 36 inch long tank offers everything you need to get started. You can go cheaper if you wait for a dollar per gallon sale at your local chain pet store and pick up a 40 gallon breeder or 55 gallon tank. 

Fluval Bow LED 45

Goldfish Tank Filtration

Goldfish in general are very hard on the bioload of an aquarium. They are large, messy, eat constantly throughout the day, and stir up your Aquarium Substrate all day. Maintaining a Goldfish tank requires a hefty filter. Keeping in mind that Goldfish are usually an entry level fish for Aquarists, we are going to focus on more budget friendly options. Our best option is a good quality aquarium Power Filter like a Hagen Aquaclear

Hagen Aquaclear

The Hagen Aquaclear is a quality made, readily available power filter that has stood the test of time. It is very easy to customize each section of the filter stages to suit your needs. It will provide years of reliable operation. Make sure you size up one model that is made for a larger aquarium. A goldfish aquarium tends to produce a lot of waste, so get try aiming for over sized filtration

Goldfish Tank Parameters (Water Quality and Goldfish)

The main thing with Goldfish tanks once you have the tank cycled is consistently monitoring your Nitrate and pH levels. Ammonia is generally a concern when you first cycle the tank or when you add new fish. Goldfish, due to their messiness and consistent desire to eat will produce a lot of waste. A full goldfish tank will usually end up running higher nitrate levels as a result. You want to test your nitrate levels regularly with a proper Aquarium Test Kit. Take care of your goldfish by ensuring your nitrates don't go above 40. This will ensure you have the best water quality possible. 

The pH levels of the your Goldfish aquarium are also critical. Goldfish like an aquarium at 7-8 pH at all times. This is different from many tropical fish and planted aquarium environments which prefer a pH at an acidic level lower than 7. Make sure your tap water has the proper pH and adjust accordingly if your tap is below 7. Always use a water conditioner like Sea Chem Prime to treat your water water. A water conditioner will remove harmful chemicals out of your tap water like ammonia and chlorine and make it aquarium safe.

Goldfish Tank Temperature

Goldfish are cold water fish. Anything over 75 degrees for a Goldfish is going to stress out your fish. Goldfish actually have a large range of temperatures that they can live in. The range is generally from 50-75 degrees F. This means that if you keep your home at room temperature, you should be fine without having an Aquarium Heater in your tank.

There are two things we have to keep in mind with Goldfish tanks. If you live in a hotter climate, you may need to control the temperature in your aquarium in the summer. This may require an Aquarium Chiller or getting your specific room where your tank is to a cooler temperature with a mobile AC. If you live in a cold climate with very cold winters, you may want to consider having a heater handy when the temperatures get below freezing in your area. 

Goldfish Tank Decorations

When we think about Decorations for a Goldfish tank, we have to consider both space and safety. Common Goldfish are fast and enjoy swimming around. Fancy Goldfish are slow, clumsy, and have delicate fins. Both types of Goldfish need their space to swim. Consider having an open aquascape when building out a Goldfish tank.

When it comes to the decor itself, we want to consider rocks, and artificial plants without sharp edges. We take the same consideration like we do with Betta Fish where we avoid sharp edge as the long fins of our Fancy Goldfish can get caught and damaged.

Marine Naturals

We turn to Marina Naturals when looking at silk artificial plants. These plants will not damage the fins of your Fancy Goldfish. You will need to keep in mind that goldfish like to dig out plants. It may be a good ideal to anchor these down with rocks.

Goldfish Tank Substrate

Goldfish love to stir the substrate in search of food. They have big mouths, so substrates that are medium or larger in size can pose a problem for them as they can accidentally shallow the pebbles. We want to make sure that goldfish have a substrate that they can easily stir and scavenge around. Knowing this, the best Goldfish Tank Substrate is going to be a sandy one. 

CaribSea Super Naturals

A sandy grain size substrate like the one pictured above from Caribsea is what we are looking for. We want to work with a thin layer of sand. This is to counteract the big pitfalls of sand substrate. Sand can compact and create anaerobic pockets, which can be very dangerous for your fish. A thin layer that barely covers the bottom of your aquarium and no more than 1/2 an inch is what we are shooting for. This sandy substrate will get stirred all day by your Goldfish and mimics their natural environment. This substrate is also pH neutral - a major factor because Goldfish need a pH of 7.2 - 7.6.

Goldfish Diet

Food for Goldfish is a an interesting topic because the industry is loaded with a lot of food targeted at beginners. These foods are cheap, easy to feed, clean, and last a long time. That is great for us humans, but they are not that great for our Goldfish.

The most basic food offered to Goldfish are flakes. Most flake food offered on the market is full of fillers, which long-term can be unhealthy for your Goldfish and creates a lot of waste. We want to upgrade the diet of our Goldfish to something better. At minimum, we want to think about a quality pellet food.

Northfin Goldfish Premium Pellets

Northfin Goldfish Formula is a premium Goldfish pellet formula specialty designed for them. It is free from fillers and includes a healthy dose of Omegea 3s to really help bring out the color in your Goldfish. I would recommend presoaking your pellets in aquarium water before you feed it to you Goldfish. This will allow for the pellets to soften and expand a bit so they don't expand in your Goldfish's gut. 

Going further, we can look into freeze dried food. I would recommend Hikari's Bio-Pure Krill. Kill has the ability to boost carotene levels in your Goldfish. This helps produce better coloration in your Goldfish. This formula is multi-vitamin enriched so you do not have to supplement with a vitamin supplement like Vita-Boost.

Hikari Bio-Pure Krill

The next step up would be frozen food. These you would likely need to purchase from your local pet or fish store. For frozen food, look for brine shrimp, blood worms or daphnia. Good brands to look at would be Hikari or Cobalt Aquatics.

Lastly we go with live foods. For live foods, I want to look at live plants. Goldfish in general, are known for eating a number of aquarium plants. While this can be bad if you are looking for a planted goldfish tank (it is possible to have plants with goldfish - more on this later), we can use this to our advantage when supplementing our Goldfish's diet. One plant that Goldfish love to eat that is fast growing and readily available in our trade is Duckweed.

Duckweed

If you are part of an Aquarium society or know anyone with a Planted Tank, there is a good change they either have Duckweed or have grown it in the past. Duckweed is also grown in ponds for Koi and Goldfish. Goldfish love to gobble this plant up. It is very cheap to obtain and a very fast grower. It is very important to have a food readily available in your aquarium for a Goldfish. We have to keep in mind that Goldfish do not have true stomachs. Because of this, they are always eating and hungry. You do need to feed goldfish regularly, but a natural food like Duckweed can really come in handy because you can make it available in your tank, it's a natural filter, and it can be eaten away by your Goldfish through out the day.

Goldfish Tank Mates

Tank mates for Goldfish can be quite tricky. They have several factors working against potential Goldfish tank mates. They are a coldwater fish, so that eliminates all tropical freshwater fish right off the bat. Fancy Goldfish also are slow and have large fins, which can be attractive to nip for a more active fish. Goldfish can also be bullies themselves. Their large size, mouths, and mass can present problems to smaller fish. For this reason, the best recommendation is to have a Goldfish only tank.

That being said, there are some tank mates that would work. These tank mates would be:

  • Coldwater snails like Nitrite and Apple Snails
  • Brittle Nose Plecos
  • Dojo Loaches

Snails are a great addition because they will work on algae in the tank and for the most part Goldfish should leave them alone. If the Goldfish do decide to harass them, they are large enough to handle themselves and give you enough time to reconsider their compatibility. Every Goldfish is different after all.

When it comes to Plecos, only the Brittle Nose Pleco is compatible with a goldfish. Common plecos are generally a bad idea as they require driftwood and can get very large.

Dojo Loach

Dojo Loaches (pictured above) are likely the best candidate when it comes to other fish in a goldfish tank. They get rather long at 5 inches and require at least a 30 gallon tank, but they can tolerate the cooler waters of a goldfish tank. They are very peaceful, very active, full of personality, and excellent scavengers. 

It's always best to introduce these new fish and inverts AFTER our goldfish have been added. We want to make sure our goldfish are established since they tend to be the ones that bullied not the other way around! You will also want to consider a larger tank if you want to have other tank mates. A 55 gallon or 75 gallon fish tank would be good options.

Live Plants for Goldfish

Goldfish Planted Tank

Plants for Goldfish like tank mates are tricky. You have a number of things working against you when it comes to them. Because Goldfish like cold water that is 7-8 in pH, this eliminate the majority of tropical aquarium plants available for sale. Goldfish also love to gobble up plants. They will eat just about any plant you stick in the tank. Another factor is that Goldfish stir up substrate, which means that if you have any rooted plants that need to be established in your substrate, it is likely that your Goldfish will dig it out.

That seems like there are a lot of things going against you when it comes to aquarium plants, but we also need to think about the benefits as well. Plants will really help with your water change efforts. They will thrive in the high nutrient environment that goldfish will create with the waste they produce. If you don't want to be a slave to water changes, live plants can be your ticket to relief. In large quantities they can act as natural filtration for your tank.

So let's talk about what plants work best. We want to make sure these plants tolerate higher pH, will do well with high nutrients, won't mind the cooler temperatures, and won't get eaten by our Goldfish. These are:

All of the plants above are considered Low Light Aquarium Plants. All you need to do to if you want aquarium plants is to upgrade your lights to a proper Planted Tank LED System. I would recommend Fluval's Planted 3.0 LED light.

Fluval Plant 3.0 LED

 

Types of Goldfish

There are a lot of different Goldfish to house in your aquarium. All goldfish are long-lived and will provide years of joy for you. I'm going to break down a small list of Goldfish for you. I'm going to split it into two types:

  • Slim Bodied Goldfish
  • Fancy Goldfish

Slim Bodied Goldfish

Slim bodied Goldfish are one of the most hardy fish you can purchase in the hobby. They can be placed in home aquariums or outdoor in ponds. They will tolerate a wide range of temperatures. They are fast swimmers, very active, and aggressive eaters. They cannot be kept with Fancy Goldfish as they will out compete them in an aquarium with how fast they swim around and eat. Below a few types of slim bodied Goldfish:

  • Common Goldfish
  • Comet Goldfish 
  • Shubunkin Goldfish 

Common Goldfish

The common Goldfish in also known as your "feeder" goldfish at pet stores. They are also the Goldfish you used to get at fairs as prizes. This Goldfish most resembles their original ancestors, the carp. They can grow as long as a foot if given a large enough aquarium or if housed in a pond. They are very hardy, very cheap, and long-lived fish.

The Comet Goldfish is a variant of the common Goldfish that has a long fancy tail. They share the same hardy characteristics of the common, but with more flash with their tails. They will also get a foot long and are fast swimmers. They a relatively cheap fish to purchase.

The Shubunkin Goldfish is a multicolored goldfish. These you will usually see placed in ponds as they get long and command a higher price tag than the former 2 mentioned. Some varieties of Shubunkin will grow fancy tails and fins.

Shubunkin Goldfish

Fancy Goldfish

Fancy Goldfish are selectively breed fish that have been created over the years. They are not found in the wild and exhibit multiple unique characteristics depending on the type. They are fish with a lot of mass on them and generally clumsy in nature. They have long elegant fins and are generally slow swimmers. Because of the slower swimming speed, they do not mix well with slim-bodied Goldfish as they will be unable to compete with them for food.

These egg shaped fish are valued for their looks. They tend to be more delicate than slim bodied Goldfish, but there are several varieties that are hardy and appropriate for beginners. A few example Fancy Goldfish are:

  • Fantail Goldfish
  • Black Moor Goldfish
  • Ryukin Goldfish
  • Lionhead Goldfish
  • Telescope

Ryukin Goldfish

The Fantail, Black Moor, and Ryukin Goldfish are great fancy varieties that are appropriate for beginners. The Lionhead and Telescope Goldfish are varieties that would be considered more delicate and better suited for experienced Goldfish keepers. The main difference between the first three and their others is what stands out with the two other fish. For the Lionhead, they are so modified that their dorsal fin is missing. Their fleshy like head and clumsy nature make them sensitive to injury. For the Telescope, it's the eyes. The eyes give them limited vision and make them delicate. It's another Fancy that is not for beginners.

I will go more detail in another blog post, but I wanted to help you identify what is a hardy Fancy Goldfish and which ones aren't. The less modified features of the fish, the more likely it will be better suited for a beginner. Of all the Fancies listed here, my personal favorite is the Ryukin. It is bold, elegant, and hardy. It is a wonderful addition to a Fancy Goldfish aquarium.

Putting It Together - Creating A Goldfish Tank

We have discussed a lot about Goldfish Tank care, food, housing, and types of Golfish. It's time to put everything we have learned today and make a comprehensive setup. In this setup, we are going to setup a Goldfish tank with live plants. You can opt not to use plants and save yourself on upgrading your light.  

To save on money, we can purchase a 40 gallon breeder to 55 gallon tank during a Pet Store's dollar per gallon sale. All the other components fit very well for this setup and for what we want to house. If you opt for a 55 gallon tank, you can house 3-5 fancy goldfish. You will want to anchor your plants to your rocks so they don't get stirred up by your Goldfish. If you opt for a dollar per gallon sale tank, you are free to select a light of your choice. I would recommend an led light like the Fluval Planted Tank 3.0 if you are selecting a light for a planted aquarium setup.

Additional Resources (Goldfish Books To Read)

There are many books out there that go beyond the scope of this blog post. However, not all are created equal. There is one book I recommend when it comes to Goldfish care.

Fancy Goldfish: Complete Guide To Care And Collecting 

Fancy Goldfish Book

This Book Written by Dr. Johnson goes over diseases, prevention, health, breeding and proper fish selection. It contains over 100 color photos of Fancy Goldfish. The information contained in this book is a full deep dive into the world of Fancy Goldfish. You will become an expert in knowledge after you read this book. It does have some outdated information given it was published back in 2001, but the majority of the information in this book I would consider evergreen. I would highly recommend to anyone who really wants to keep the more exotic Fancy Goldfish or considering expanding into larger display tanks.

Closing Thoughts on Goldfish Tank Care

Goldfish go way beyond the fish in the bowl that money of us have seen in the past. There are many varieties of Goldfish with some of the exotic Fancy types selling for hundreds of dollars. They are large fish with personality and unique aesthetics. They do require larger tanks long-term, but they are long-live fish easily living over 10 years in more aquariums. I hope I showed you what Goldfish can offer you as a pet by reading this post. If you have any questions, leave a comment below. Thank you for reading.

 

 





Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in The AquariumStoreDepot.com blog

Best Aquarium Air Pump
Best Aquarium Air Pumps - 2020 Reviews and Guide

March 09, 2020

Aquarium Air Pumps are great tools for adding oxygen in your aquarium. They are simple, cheap, easy to install and operate, and readily available to purchase. They also can really come in handy in the event of a power outage. I feel every freshwater tank should have an air pump solution. Air pumps are great for your display tank as a source of oxygen delivery. They are also great for backup purposes in the event of a power outage.

View full article →

Betta Fish Care
Betta Fish Care - Create A Thriving Betta Tank

February 09, 2020

The Betta Fish for some of us fish keepers was our first experience with a pet fish. It was our introduction into this wonderful world of aquarium keeping. Betta Fish after all have a lot going for them that make them great pets. They have a great personality and come in a variety of colors. They can exist in smaller tanks and can be relatively hardy as long as the environment is properly cared for. 

View full article →

Dutch Aquascape
Dutch Aquascape - How To And Guide On Dutch Style Aquariums

January 19, 2020

I continue our Aquascaping series with the Dutch Aquascape this week. Also known as the Dutch Style Aquarium or Dutch Style Aquascape, this style is considered one of the more pure and more maintenance intensive styles in our hobby. Its tradition dates back further than the Iwagumi Aquascape before hardscaping really became a major factor in aquascape. If you are looking for an eye popping aquascaping style that is very colorful and plant only, this is the style you are looking for. 

View full article →