The Best Substrate for Planted Tanks – 2019 Reviews & Guide

November 17, 2019

The Best Substrate for Planted Tanks – 2019 Reviews & Guide

As we mentioned in our Best Low Light Aquarium Plants article. There are some plants that require rich substrates to thrive and others that are column feeders. Today's post we are going to concentrate on selecting the best substrate for your planted tank. There are many factors that go into selecting the best substrate and there are a ton of questions aquarists want answered before they they start planting. I will go through as much as I can in this post to provide you the best information possible and then suggest several great substrates that should work for your planted aquarium. These suggestions will have affiliate links (Just so you know I may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page - learn more). The links are included for you to have an quick and convenient way of purchasing them if you choose so. With that quick disclosure out of the way, let's first start with some definitions.

What Is An Aquarium Substrate?

We have to first start with this definition because we have to state the purpose of our substrate. Substrate is going to be gravel or some other specialty material that will be used to root plants in the aquarium. These plants will root in this substrate and use the nutrients in the substrate to grow and sustain themselves. It is also fair to point out though that most plants are water column feeders, which means they will derive nutrients from your water not your from the substrate. Several of the low light plants we mentioned in our prior post are  column feeders.

However, some of the larger and more diverse plants in the industry are root feeders. these would include plants like Amazon Swords, Vallisneria, and Crypts. These also include the most highly sought after high end carpeting plants. 

Why Do We Need A Planted Tank Substrate? 

This is another good question because of plants do feed on the substrate, why do we need to go out of way to purchase a specialty plant substrate for them. Most of the planted substrate packages will tell you that it has nutrients that allow plants to grow, which is true. However, let's dive in deeper. the planted substrates will be rich in nutrients that will actually rot in your tank and release nutrients in your aquarium. Your plants will then consume it --- if you select the correct plants. If you purchase a planted substrate, but you purchase plants that are water feeders like Java Fern what will happen is that your nutrient levels will spike and the other thing that is going to consume these high levels will be algae --- lots of algae. That's why we need to be careful when we select what substrate to purchase and what plants will be placed in the aquarium. These substrates will be rich in nutrients early on when your plants are small which will allow them to grow and establish in your aquarium. 

Most substrates will typically stay rich in nutrients for about 1-2 years. At this point, we will need to renew the substrate as the nutrient levels in the substrate will be begin to get exhausted. This will then require us to renew the soil will additional supplements such as Root Tabs so you can continue to re-materialize the substrate. 

If you do decide to focus mainly on plants that are water column feeders, your options for substrates will open up. You can select just about any substrate you want that pleases your eye and be successful with column feeder plants like Anubias and Java Fern.

Types of Planted Tank Substrates

Let's discuss the types of substrates now. There are several we can discuss here. They are:

Clay Based

Clay based substrates are our first set of inert substrates. Inert substrates will not alter the chemistry of your aquarium. These hard baked clay substrates will last forever and are the easiest planted aquarium substrates to manage. They will require fertilization if you plan to use root plants in your aquarium.

Sand

Sand is another inert substrate commonly used. The main issue with sand is if it is not course, there is a possibility that the sand will not be suitable for plants. Keep this in mind if you are considering this.

Gravel Based

Gravel based substrates that the standard substrates you will see at a fish store or chain pet store. They can come in a variety of colors and shapes and do not offer nutrients. They are typically best served for fish only or water column planted tanks. Like clay based substrates, they will not alter water chemistry.

Materialized Substrates

A good example of this is SeaChem's Aquasolum. This is a materialized porous substrate. It tends to lower pH and soften water. It is ideal for keeping freshwater shrimp and root based planted tanks. Other types of these commercially available soils are Flourite and EcoComplete.

Important Factors In Choosing Planted Tank Aquarium Substrates

It's really easy to get lost in the various types of aquarium substrates available and what they do. It's best for me to outline what the critical factors are when you select a substrate for your planted tank. They are the following:

Grain Size

Too think of a grain size and your root feeders will not be able to feed off the substrate. Too small and it will compact the substrate choking the roots out. Too fie of a substrate will also be stirred too easily by fish and inverts in your aquarium. For grain size you will want a range of 1-3 mm with 2mm generally being the sweet spot.

Material

As we discussed previously, material of the substrate matters. We generally want to avoid materials that increase hardness or pH. These would include substrates like coral sand or limestone chips. For ease, just follow the products we recommend in this post as it will eliminate the guesswork.

CEC Value

This is also known as cation exchange capacity. This reflects the substrates ability to bind fertilizers and other elements in it. Generally the higher the better as substrates with higher CEC values will hold nutrients better in the substrate for plants to utilize.

Weight

Some plants have delicate or small roots. A heavy or large substrate may cause difficulties when handling these. It's sometime to consider depending on your overall plant selection.

The Best Substrate For Planted Tanks

Now that we are talked about why we need a substrate and type of substrates, let's talk about the best available on the market. Below is a list of recommended substrates for a planted aquarium.

Picture Name Links
ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia
ADA Aqua Soil Amazon Light ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia Light
Carib Sea Eco Complete CaribSea EcoComplete
Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum Fluval Stratum 
Mr Aqua Aquarium Soil Mr. Aqua Aquarium Soil
Tropica Aquarium Soil Tropica Aquarium Soil
Seachem Flourite Seachem Flourite Black

 

1. ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia - The Most Famous Planted Tank Soil

ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia

ADA Amazonia substrate mix that is known around the world by expert aquascapers. It lowers the hardness and pH levels to make the water mildy acidic, which is preferred by most tropical fish and plants. The substrate contains a rich amount of ammonia and phosphate. The main issue with this substrate that it is very rich in nutrients and a newly planted tank will suffer from very high nutrients in during the establishment period. This will cause algae breaks and cloudy water and lots of water changes during the 8 week establishment period of the substrate. Some aquarists mitigate this issue by doing a planted tank dry start. Since the nutrients in this substrate is so high, it is easier to grow out new plants via the dry start method making this substrate a very popular one for this method.

This can frustrate some newcomers into the planted tank world. It also breaks down over time, requiring replenishment every 1-2 years as the substrate breaks down. This can be a major problem when it comes time to replace the soil if you aren't careful as the substrate will leech out ammonia. It is really a substrate that is best in an experienced aquarists hands. It is also an expensive substrate due to its high production quality and name brand.

Pros

  • Very rich in nutrients
  • Well known field results with the best aquascapers in the world
  • Designed for expert level plants

Cons

  • Will leech ammonia when first placed in the tank
  • Expensive
  • Takes about 8 weeks to establish

2. ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia Light - Beginner Friendly ADA Soil

ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia Light

ADA Amazonia Light is a more beginner friendly ADA soil. This substrate has a lower amount of nutrients. This means that there will be less of a establishment period and there will be less algae spikes when the plants are first getting established. This substrate lowers the hardness and pH levels to make the water mildy acidic, which is preferred by most tropical fish and plants. For those looking for ADA soils but don't want as big of a disruptive 8 week cycle period, this is a better substrate to start with. I definitely recommend this over the other ADA product.

Pros

  • Very rich in nutrients
  • Well known field results with the best aquascapers in the world
  • Less nutrients than standard ADA Amazonia product

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Takes about 8 weeks to establish

3. CaribSea EcoComplete - The Most Famous Planted Tank Soil

Caribsea EcoComplete

Caribsea Eco Complete is a balanced substrate that is packed with liquid fertilizer. The soil holds the fertilizer within it for easy absorption. It has the added benefit of not decreasing pH or hardness in the long term. This gives you the advantage of having a substrate that is inert in nature, but also has the benefits of a commercial substrate. It comes in either a red or black color. It also has the added benefit of already having beneficial bacteria colony growing on it. This will reduce your cycle time when establishing a tank. The other added benefit is that it has a good amount of iron in it, making it better suited for red colored plants.

The main issue with this substrate is that is it lightweight and may have issues anchoring larger plants. It's shape is also not ideal for bottom dwellers.

Pros

  • Contains beneficial bacteria
  • Inert substrate
  • No washing necessary

Cons

  • Lightweight
  • Reasonable price
  • Substrate not the best for bottom dwellers

 

4. Fluval Stratum - Volcanic Soil for Aquariums

Fluval Stratum Review

Fluval Stratum is a specialty substrate that is designed for shrimp tanks. It made of Volcanic soil and is a porous material that establishes a ton of beneficial bacteria. It will also naturally lower pH making this ideal for most tropical fish and plants. It also tends not to discolor water when first placed into the tank. 

One tip when placing in this substrate is to make sure the substrate is not under the rock or driftwood you are using. The substrate is easy to break under pressure and one it breaks, it loses its use in the tank.

The main downfalls I see with with this substrate is that it can be lightweight and easy to siphon out when cleaning the tank. It also is on par in price with ADA substrates.

Pros

  • Natural Volcanic based substrate
  • Waters great with smaller tanks
  • Soil has a high CEC value

Cons

  • Lightweight - easy to siphon away substrate when cleaning
  • Expensive

5. Mr Aqua Aquarium Soil - ADA Amazonia Aquasoil on a Budget

Mr Aqua Aquarium Soil Review

Mr Aqua Aquarium Soil is an aquarium substrate that is similar to ADA aquasoil, but less rich in ammonia. The porous granular structure of this substrate helps with water exchange. It will soften water and lower pH like most of the soils on this list.

I find this as a good cheaper alternative for those who want ADA quality soil, but not the ADA quality price. It can be tough to find locally though, but the link I have provided above makes it easier to purchase.

Pros

  • Cheaper than ADA soil but of similar quality
  • Lowers pH and softens water
  • Less ammonia - easier to cycle time for establishment

Cons

  • Harder to find in store

6. Tropica Aquarium Soil - Balance Aquarium Substrate from Europe

Tropica Aquarium Soil Review

Tropica Aquarium Soil is a substrate brand in Europe that is well known. It is similiar to ADA aquasoil, but will not leech as much ammonia as the standard ADA aquasoil. Its grain is not uniform as well, giving a more natural looking substrate. Like most of the substrates on this list, it will lower pH and hardness making it ideal for most tropical fish and plants. 

Pros

  • Leeches less ammonia then ADA soil
  • More natural grain variety and shape
  • Lowers pH and hardness

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Hard to find

7. Seachem Florite - Reliable Clay Based Substrate

Seachem Flourite Black Review

Seachem Flourite is a clay based substrate that you will not need to replace over time in your aquarium. It comes in several colors and grain types so you can find the substrate that works for you with this brand. Being clay based, it will not alter your tank chemistry so you can use supplements to adjust your parameters as necessary.

It is not nutrient loaded like say ADA or Mr. Aqua, but that also means that you will not experience the algae outbreaks that these substrates experience during the first couple of months. It is also not suited for bottom dwellers given it's sharp structure. That can be a bit of downer if you are are into bottom dwelling fish like Corys.

Pros

  • Several colors and types available
  • Doesn't break down because it's clay based

Cons

  • Messy to work with
  • Not nutrient loaded
  • Not suited for bottom dwellers

Going the DIY Route

There is another popular route for aquarists to go to when it comes to a planted tank. This would involve using garden/top soil as a base and then "capping" the soil with coarse sand or one of the products listed above in our list to save on money. This is a viable option that can lead to lots of success, but it is really a mention best suited for someone who has experience with planted tanks. For one, it can be difficult to find the correct soil for your planted tank because many of these soils are not studied or observed for aquarium usage. This means you may not know how your parameters shift when you place this soil in the tank. They will also leech ammonia like crazy so you may have an extended cycle and they will break down the fastest of all substrates. I feel that it is something that should be attempted by an experienced hobbyist and generally out of the scope of this post.

The Best Planted Tank Substrate (Our Recommendation)

Of all the substrates listed here, I feel that the Caribsea EcoComplete achieves the best combination of being beginner friendly and having a substrate that can absorb nutrients. 

If you are venturing towards a more soil based substrates, you can't go wrong with ADA or it's lower priced clones like Mr. Aqua.

Closing Thoughts on Best Planted Tank Substrate

There are a variety of substrates available on the market and it can make the a bit mind racking to determine what is best. The best place to start is to see what types of plants and setups you want and then journey to your substrate from there. If you are going with mostly column feeding plants, you can go with an insert substrate and have great success. If you are are planning to go with mostly root feeders, you will want to have a soil based substrate like an ADA or Mr. Aqua and need to work with the cycle period or consider dry starting the aquarium. If you have any questions, please feel free to leave a comment below. Thanks for reading.

 

 

 

 

 





Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in The AquariumStoreDepot.com blog

Best CO2 System for Planted Aquarium – (2019 Reviews)
Best CO2 System for Planted Aquarium – (2019 Reviews)

November 24, 2019

Today's post is all about CO2 systems for planted aquariums. Usually when people start out trying plants in a aquarium they want to go without CO2 injection. There are many reasons for this including intimation factors, costs, complexity, and lack of information. The fact of the matter is if you want an eye popping prizing winning planted aquascape, A quality CO2 system and injection protocol is necessary. 

View full article →

Best Low Light Aquarium Plants - Making An Easy to Keep Planted Tank
Best Low Light Aquarium Plants - Making An Easy to Keep Planted Tank

November 10, 2019

Many of us who want a planted tank want to have an easy to maintain tank that that doesn't really take a ton of effort to keep up. Today's post is all about that. The list we will make today will help you find plants that are easy to maintain and grow fast to provide a great aquascape for your planted tank. These plants are low light aquarium plants, which means they will not require sizable investments in powerful lights to keep. Many of them will thrive without CO2 supplementation, which will also save you money in the long-run. 

All these plants are readily available as well. They are relevantly cheap and easy to find available. With that, let's go ahead and get started!

View full article →

Best Auto Top Off System - Keeping Your Aquarium Stable (2019 Reviews)
Best Auto Top Off System - Keeping Your Aquarium Stable (2019 Reviews)

October 20, 2019

Aquarium automatic is becoming more and more of a reality to the modern aquarist these days. One of the most common applications of tank automation are auto top of systems (AKA ATOs). These systems work to add freshwater to your aquarium as water evaporates. In saltwater tanks in particular, they are extremely valuable in maintaining stable salinity levels as salinity can swing as water evaporates and does not get replaced. In freshwater tanks, this will keep your water levels stable so your filtration can run optimally and so your tank doesn't completely dry out.

View full article →